Skip to content
2015 Federal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayAloke ChakravartyWilliam D. WeinrebTimothy G. WatkinsEdward S. KnappJennifer HammersDavid McCollamdirectcrossredirectDay 40 - March 26, 2015David McCollam testified about explosive materials and limits of residue testing. Edward S. Knapp described bomb reconstructions and demonstrated separate remote-control systems; the court excluded proposed transmitter-range evidence. Jennifer Hammers testified about Krystle Marie Campbell's fatal blast injuries and gave a qualified survival-time estimate over a defense objection.
← Day 392015 Federal TrialDay 41 →

Day 40 - March 26, 2015

Explosives Analysis, Device Reconstructions, and Campbell Autopsy Testimony

Judge George A. O'Toole Jr.
8Proceedings
4Pages
3Witnesses
1,731Lines
4Sidebars
Day 40 of 67
Appearing:

David McCollam testified about explosive materials and limits of residue testing. Edward S. Knapp described bomb reconstructions and demonstrated separate remote-control systems; the court excluded proposed transmitter-range evidence. Jennifer Hammers testified about Krystle Marie Campbell's fatal blast injuries and gave a qualified survival-time estimate over a defense objection.

Full day summary

FBI chemist David McCollam testified that residues from both Boylston Street scenes were consistent with burned pyrotechnic material and that Watertown bulk powder was pyrotechnic flash-powder-type material. He reported pyrotechnic residues in Norfolk Street filters and on Honda CR-V gloves, plus physical black powder grains in four Norfolk Street samples. His testing identified substances but did not measure their quantities or identify a specific assembly location. The court excluded an undisclosed expert opinion comparing residue amounts with the explosives involved. On cross-examination, McCollam distinguished the findings on individual gloves and said filters recorded as coming from a UMass Dartmouth dorm room screened negative for the typical explosive-residue traces tested by the laboratory. His knowledge of collection locations came from information supplied with the samples. On redirect, he discussed intact fireworks attributed to the dorm room through laboratory submissions and intact pyrotechnic mixture in a landfill bag. An objection prevented an answer about a single device-production location. FBI hazardous-device examiner Edward S. Knapp described the Boylston Street pressure-cooker bombs and Watertown devices. He compared recovered fragmentation with an Inspire article and demonstrated reconstructed remote-control systems. Scene B's Spektrum receiver was incompatible with the recovered Flysky transmitter; the original Scene B transmitter had not been found. Separate exemplar transmitters activated the mockups independently, but Scene B's original transmitter configuration and exact operating ranges remained unknown. The court allowed exhibition of the mockups while reserving admission. During cross-examination, it excluded proposed transmitter-range evidence under Rule 403 at sidebar. Knapp also discussed purchase records, including an R/C car receipt bearing Tamerlan Tsarnaev's name. Jennifer Hammers testified that Krystle Marie Campbell died from blast injuries, with damaged blood vessels causing fatal blood loss. Over a defense objection concerning disclosure and foundation, the court allowed her estimate that Campbell could have survived from seconds to approximately a minute. Autopsy photographs were shown to the jury, not on public monitors. The defense asked no questions, and the court adjourned until Monday.

1. David McCollam — Direct/Cross/Redirect

FBI chemist David McCollam described explosive-residue findings and limits on what the testing established. Cross-examination addressed negative dorm-room filter results and sample origins; the court excluded an undisclosed residue-comparison opinion.

→
Procedural
Admission of Redacted Exhibit 1387A and Permission to Use Photographs
12 lines
Direct
Direct Examination - David McCollam David McCollam Aloke Chakravarty
219 lines

David McCollam described explosive-residue findings and testing limits; the court excluded an undisclosed residue-proportionality opinion.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Undisclosed Explosive Residue Proportionality OpinionCounsel disputed whether comparing trace residues with the amount of explosives potentially involved would elicit an undisclosed expert opinion.
Cross
Cross-Examination - David McCollam David McCollam Timothy G. Watkins
133 lines

McCollam clarified glove and drawer-item findings and reported negative explosive-residue screening of dormitory vacuum filters.

Redirect
Redirect Examination - David McCollam David McCollam Aloke Chakravarty
20 lines

McCollam contrasted trace residues with intact explosive materials; the court sustained an objection to a production-location question.

Highlights

3. Edward S. Knapp — Direct/Cross (Part 2)

Edward S. Knapp completed testimony about the bombs’ components and independent remote-control systems. Cross-examination addressed evidence handling and purchase records. The court excluded proposed transmitter-range evidence and, after Knapp’s excusal, announced limits on displaying upcoming autopsy photographs.

→
Direct
Direct Examination - Edward S. Knapp (Resumed) Edward S. Knapp Aloke Chakravarty
301 lines

Knapp compared Inspire descriptions with recovered bomb materials and demonstrated separate remote-control systems; the court reserved admission of the mockups.

Cross
Cross-Examination - Edward S. Knapp Edward S. Knapp Timothy G. Watkins
223 lines

Knapp's cross-examination tested reconstruction and forensic limits; the court excluded transmitter-range evidence under Rule 403.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Transmitter Range Evidence Excluded Under Rule 403Counsel disputed using transmitter-range measurements in an expert’s report for impeachment or refreshing recollection, with prosecutors arguing the evidence would mislead and confuse the jury.

Highlights

4. Jennifer Hammers — Direct

Jennifer Hammers described Krystle Marie Campbell’s fatal blast injuries and estimated survival from seconds to approximately a minute. The defense asked no questions, and the court adjourned until Monday morning.

→
Direct
Direct Examination - Jennifer Hammers Jennifer Hammers William D. Weinreb
224 lines

Hammers attributed Campbell's death to blast injuries and blood loss; the court allowed a survival estimate of seconds to approximately a minute over defense objections.

1 sidebar inside this proceeding
  1. Objection to Survival-Time EstimateThe defense challenged notice and the basis for a proposed survival-time estimate of up to one minute, closer to one minute than zero.

Highlights

← Day 392015 Federal TrialDay 41 →