Skip to content
2015 Federal TrialtranscripttranscriptCeleste Corcoran — Direct - Day 49 - 2015 Federal TrialCeleste Corcoran described the bombing, the loss of both legs, her continuing injuries, and Sydney’s injuries. The court admitted two exhibits over renewed defense objections before a recess.
Steven D. MellinJudy ClarkeGeorge A. O'Toole Jr.Celeste CorcoranCourt ClerkCeleste CorcoranMR. MELLINMS. CLARKETHE COURTdirect
2015 Federal Trial/Day 49/April 21, 2015
13 pages·5 witnesses·1,486 lines
The penalty phase opened with evidence rulings, sentencing instructions and the prosecution's request for death. Jurors heard injury testimony from Celeste Corcoran, Gillian Reny and Nicole Gross, and family-impact testimony from Krystle Campbell's brother and father. The defense moved for a mistrial after Corcoran's testimony; no express disposition was recorded.
← Day 48Day 50 →
DirectDirectDirect Examination - Celeste Corcoran Celeste Corcoran Steven D. Mellin

CELESTE CORCORAN, duly sworn

COURT CLERK: Have a seat. State your name and spell your last name for the record, if you would, please.

CELESTE CORCORAN: My name is Celeste Corcoran, C-E-L-E-S-T-E, C-O-R-C-O-R-A-N.

DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. MELLIN:

MR. MELLIN: Good morning, Ms. Corcoran. I think it's still morning. Can you pull the microphone maybe just a little bit closer to you?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: That's much better. Thanks a lot. Miss Corcoran, where did you grow up?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I grew up in Lowell, Massachusetts.

MR. MELLIN: At some point did you graduate from high school?

MR. MELLIN: And where was that?

CELESTE CORCORAN: It was a vocational high school.

MR. MELLIN: Okay. Did you meet Kevin Corcoran at some point?

MR. MELLIN: And who is Kevin Corcoran?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Kevin is my husband.

MR. MELLIN: When did you meet?

CELESTE CORCORAN: We met as teenagers through a family friend.

MR. MELLIN: At some point did you get married?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes, we did. In 1989.

MR. MELLIN: And when was that --

MR. MELLIN: -- if you remember. Do you remember when you got married?

(Laughter.)

MR. MELLIN: Do you have any children?

MR. MELLIN: How many children?

MR. MELLIN: Who are they?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Tyler; he's 22. And Sydney will have her birthday in just a couple of days, and she's going to be 20.

MR. MELLIN: And Sydney previously testified in this courtroom. Is that right?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes, she did.

MR. MELLIN: After you graduated from high school, did you begin work?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I did. I started working as a hairstylist immediately.

MR. MELLIN: And did you continue to work as a hairstylist up until the time of April of 2013?

MR. MELLIN: And around that time, where were you working?

MR. MELLIN: Where were you working?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I was working at Emerge Spa & Salon on Newbury Street.

MR. MELLIN: Do you know where Newbury Street is in relation to Boylston Street?

CELESTE CORCORAN: It's parallel to it.

MR. MELLIN: Okay. It's just one block over running parallel?

MR. MELLIN: Okay. And how long had you worked on Newbury Street?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I believe it's been about 15 years, 14 years.

MR. MELLIN: On April the 15th of 2013, did you go to the Boston Marathon?

MR. MELLIN: Why did you attend?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I went because my sister, Carmen, my only sister, was running the marathon.

MR. MELLIN: Had you ever run a marathon?

(Laughter.)

CELESTE CORCORAN: No. And this was her first marathon. It was supposed to be a one-and-done. And I watched her train so hard, and there was no way that my entire family was going to miss her running that marathon. I had never been to the Boston Marathon myself.

MR. MELLIN: So on the morning of April 15, what did you do?

CELESTE CORCORAN: We left Lowell very early. One of my friends lives close by, and she has a parking spot for us to stay -- to park in. And I was very worried about parking and road closings and everything, so we went early. We left Lowell probably about 8:30 in the morning, and so got to Boston fairly early. And I just remember that it was such a beautiful day. And we had so much time, so we went on Commonwealth Ave, in that little grassy area, I think it's called the mall, and we had some Dunkin' Donuts, we talked. It was my husband, my daughter and I.

MR. MELLIN: And when you say your daughter, Sydney?

CELESTE CORCORAN: And then when I work, I usually, you know, go to work and then go home, and I don't explore the city that much. So we decided that we had enough time, I had said that I had never walked over the Arthur Fiedler Footbridge, so we decided to take a little stroll. And we walked over that and we went over to the Hatch Shell. I had never been in that area before. And we walked out onto -- closer to the water, onto this little pier, you know, where there were these chairs there. And I just remember it being so beautiful. We were sitting in the sun. And I remember sitting sideways in my chair, and I just kind of put my feet up on the back of the -- on the side of the chair and just kind of, you know, raising my face to the sun and just thinking that it was such a beautiful day.

MR. MELLIN: When you talk about the water, that's the Charles River right there?

MR. MELLIN: After that, where did you go?

CELESTE CORCORAN: We made our way back to Newbury Street. We met up with friends of ours, Ron and Karen Brassard, and their daughter Krystara. We were tracking my sister through our cell phones and stuff, so we knew that we still had some time. So the girls split off and we went into a couple of little shops, and the guys went to Joe's for a beer, and we agreed to meet maybe, like, an hour later. We knew -- because we knew that it was close to the time that my sister -- we wanted to be at the finish line maybe -- you know, the tracking device wasn't extremely accurate, so we wanted to be there in plenty of time to absolutely not miss her. So actually, then we -- when we did meet up, we ate at Stephanie's restaurant on Newbury Street.

MR. MELLIN: And do you know what cross-street that's at? Is that at Exeter?

MR. MELLIN: Do you know what cross-street that is at?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I believe it's --

MR. MELLIN: Is it Exeter?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Exeter. I think it's Exeter.

MR. MELLIN: All right.

CELESTE CORCORAN: So when we were done eating lunch, we decided that it was time to make our way up onto Boylston Street. And we went up Exeter and --

MR. MELLIN: At that time who was all together as a group?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So it was myself, my husband Kevin, Sydney, Ron and Karen Brassard, their daughter Krystara, and Krystara had called her roommate Victoria, I believe her last name was McGrath.

MR. MELLIN: All right.

CELESTE CORCORAN: And we all made our way to Boylston Street. And at that point my husband pointed out that we were -- we were going to stay right there, and he was like, "Okay. We're behind the finish line. You're not going to see her finish." So he made the call that we should all move towards the finish line. So we followed him and got to -- a couple of times along the way we tried to get him to stop because we thought we were close enough, but we ended up in front of Marathon Sports, and that's where we stopped to watch.

MR. MELLIN: Your Honor, if I could have, just for the witness right now, Exhibit 1594.

MR. MELLIN: Mrs. Corcoran, do you see the exhibit in front of you now on the screen?

MR. MELLIN: And is that a photograph of where you were standing along Boylston Street at the marathon?

MR. MELLIN: And as you look at it, in fact, do you see yourself in the photograph?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I'm right here (indicating). Will that show?

MR. MELLIN: It's actually -- if you could just answer "yes" or "no" for right now.

CELESTE CORCORAN: Oh, I'm sorry.

MR. MELLIN: Do you see yourself in that photograph?

MR. MELLIN: And Sydney, and your husband Kevin as well?

MR. MELLIN: Okay. And is that a fair and accurate picture of where you were standing at that time?

MR. MELLIN: Your Honor, I would move into evidence Exhibit 1594.

MS. CLARKE: Subject to the previously noted objection.

THE COURT: All right. It's admitted over the objection.

MR. MELLIN: And if it may be published, please? Thank you.

(Government Exhibit No. 1594 received into evidence.)

BY MR. MELLIN:

MR. MELLIN: Now, Mrs. Corcoran, you were about to touch the screen. Can you please circle yourself in this photograph?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: Thank you. And you drew a circle around the person who is actually identified as Celeste Corcoran, right?

MR. MELLIN: Okay. And there's also a line drawn to Sydney and a line drawn to your husband Kevin as well. Is that right?

MR. MELLIN: All right.

MR. MELLIN: We could take that down, Mr. Bruemmer. Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: Mrs. Corcoran, shortly after you got to that location there by the flags, what happened?

CELESTE CORCORAN: We -- I remember being a little frustrated because we were maybe six or seven people deep from the fence and my -- I was determined that I was going to see my sister -- I needed to see my sister cross the finish line. So Sydney at the time was taller than me, and I was kind of using her shoulder to kind of lift myself up. And I just remember my head being on a swivel, looking back and forth, you know. And we would yell back and forth to each other, like, "Did you see it? Did you see anything?" And we were just waiting and waiting. And then Ron and Karen sort of -- I didn't know because I was so attuned to watching the street, but Ron and Karen had sort of -- we had sort of spread out a little bit, but Sydney did stay next to me. And at that point I think my husband had -- was joking around with Ron and Karen and -- about the signs. Karen had made some signs to cheer my sister on. And then our whole world just exploded.

MR. MELLIN: What do you remember about the explosion?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I, unfortunately, remember every single detail. I did not pass out. I remember being thrown up in the air, or having the sensation of kind of flipping around. I remember just, like, landing hard, not being able to breathe. I remember this thick, thick, black, heavy smoke. I was choking. I was trying to spit stuff out of my mouth. I was completely confused. I didn't know what had happened. There was this -- it's so hard to describe. It was like this deafening silence. And when I opened my eyes and, you know, could see the black smoke and everything, I could hear -- my eardrums got blown out. So I just remember that being so irritating, like, why can't I hear? It was like my mind hadn't caught up yet with what had happened. And I remember hearing just blood-curdling screams. I remember just looking around, not really seeing -- just seeing blood everywhere, sort of, like, debris falling from the sky. It was such a surreal kind of out-of-body experience. It's very hard to explain but I want to try and get it right for you all to understand. And I just remember lying there, and I think as my brain was kind of catching up, I just remember thinking, like, what was that, you know? And...

MR. MELLIN: As you lay there, did you look around and could you see what was around you? You mentioned blood but --

CELESTE CORCORAN: I saw blood. I saw a lot of blood. And when I had flipped, I remember feeling someone. I pushed off of someone or something. Our bodies collided or something. And I don't know who that was. And I remember trying to sit up, and I couldn't sit up. And I remember looking down, and I just saw -- as much as I could sit up and look down, I just remember seeing so much blood where my legs were and my -- one of my feet at a weird angle. And I just remember inside my head as it started to kind of process, like the pain started -- I started to feel the pain. And I just remember thinking, No, no. I want it to be five minutes ago. Like what just happened? This can't be happening. This can't be reality. And nothing went away, you know? Everything stayed the same, and the pain increased.

MR. MELLIN: At that time, did you know where Sydney was?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I did not. I did not. Right away my husband came down. I saw him. He was right in my face, and he was touching my hair and he was telling me it was going to be okay. He literally said the words to me, "This was a terrorist bomb" or attack. I don't remember exactly which word he used, but he said "terrorist." He said, "This is a terrorist attack" or bomb. And I remember thinking, I don't care. Like just what -- I just remember thinking how awful this was and how this had to stop. This couldn't be real. Couldn't be real. And then he started to apply pressure on my legs. And I was just in such excruciating pain and there was so much screaming and chaos that it was like I just had to kind of -- to kind of keep it together I just had to kind of go into myself, and I just raised my arms to cover my eyes because I didn't want to look at anything else.

MR. MELLIN: At that time what were you thinking was going to happen to you?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I didn't know. I just remember how much I hurt. And I think it was at that point that I asked my husband -- I said, "Kevin, are my feet attached to my legs?" and he said yes. And they were. And then I don't know how much longer after that, because he kept applying pressure and I was just in so much pain, but in my head -- because he was okay and he was tending to me, I thought that Sydney was okay. Like I knew that other people obviously were hurt because of all the screaming and the blood and everything that I saw, but I thought that she was okay. And I said to him, "How's Sydney?" thinking that she would be devastated to see me because I knew how hurt -- or I suspected how hurt I was. And he didn't know. Sydney got blown back from us but he thought -- he said, "I think she's okay. I think she's with Ron and Karen." So that, thankfully, let me kind of calm down and try and just keep it together until -- all I could think of was -- I just kept going over and over in my head, No, no, no. This doesn't happen here. This doesn't -- this couldn't have happened. I'm dreaming. I'm going to wake up, something.

MR. MELLIN: At some point did someone apply tourniquets to your legs?

CELESTE CORCORAN: My husband did.

MR. MELLIN: To both legs?

CELESTE CORCORAN: He did. He took his belt off and applied one to one of my legs, and then he stopped someone walking past us and he got his belt and he applied the other tourniquet. And then he just kept putting this excruciating pressure on my legs. And he kind of crouched down beside me, and he was trying to keep me calm because he knew that I was on the verge of freaking out. And he just kept -- I'll never forget. He just kept touching my head and taking my hair away from my face, and he just kept telling me that he loved me and that I was going to live and he wasn't going to leave my side and that it was going to be okay. "Hold on. Hold on. It's going to be okay." And he said, "I'm not going to leave."

MR. MELLIN: At some point were you moved from that scene?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes. They -- I'm assuming the ambulance people came to get me. They put me on a board or gurney. I have no idea what. I just know that when they moved me, I think that was the first time that I had breath enough to scream in agony, them moving me, because it hurt my legs so bad. And then I remember them taking me into the medical tent. And inside the medical tent there was like this like controlled chaos. Like you could tell that everybody was sort of frantic but trying to hold it together. People were yelling. They were cutting my clothes off me. I remember them cutting through my top and I remember them writing on my chest a number. They said -- I said, "What are you doing?" And they said, "We're writing a number on you." I believe they said they were writing the number one. I can't be positive about that but -- she said she was writing a number on my chest because they had to get me out fast. And I just remember them saying, "She needs to leave. She needs to leave now. Get her out of here."

MR. MELLIN: At that point what are you feeling?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Excruciating pain. Inside there, I don't remember any of their faces because, again, I had -- I guess that was my defense, I had my arms up and I was just trying to just breathe. I had never felt pain like that before in my life and I just was trying to hold it together. And all I could think was, Okay. They're going to get me to the hospital, they're going to fix my legs. They're going to knock me out, I'm going to go into surgery, they're going to fix my legs. It's going to be okay. I just have to hang on until they get me to the hospital. They just have to get me to the hospital.

MR. MELLIN: Did you look down to the see the extent of the injuries at that time?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I think because I was just in too much pain. I didn't care. It just hurt too much. It wasn't relevant at that point. It was just I was in too much pain to move. Any movement was just horrific. I remember thinking that I was going to die, that I couldn't -- no one can go through that much pain. And I didn't know how bad it was. I knew it was very bad and I was just thinking, Is this it? Is this -- am I going to die? And I remember thinking that I wanted to die. I remember thinking that the pain was too much and I just wanted to die. And then on the heels of that, I remember almost instantaneously it was like -- I don't know if it was the mom in me or, you know, just -- I don't know where it came from but I just remember thinking, I just want to die, just let me die, and then immediately I was like, Hell no. I don't want to die. Please don't let me die, you know? Then that was the mantra, sort of, that I was saying. And it was like, I can't die. I have to be there for my kids. I have to be there for my husband. I have too much living to do. Don't let this be the end. How can this be the end?

MR. MELLIN: Do you remember what hospital you were taken to?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I don't remember them telling me that, I don't think, but I know I went to Boston Medical Center.

MR. MELLIN: And when you got to Boston Medical Center, what happened?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So they wheeled me in. So I do know that when we left the tent, I know that Kevin was with me, and I know that they told him to ride in the front of the ambulance. And there was a woman in the ambulance with me, I don't know who that was, but the attendant was trying to go between the two of us. And when we got to the hospital and they wheeled me in, again, it was that controlled chaos, like everybody moving so fast that you -- like I, again, shut my eyes. Like they're like running you down the hallway and people are yelling instructions at each other and you just know -- you can hear in their voice how serious this is so it scares the hell out of you. But at the same time they're trying to comfort you, you know. And they were cutting my clothes off, and one nurse was at my head and she was asking me what my name was. And at that point I remember feeling -- I was so cold, and I remember -- I remember my hands, they felt like they were like cramping up. Like I remember trying to, like -- I don't know what I was trying to do, if I was trying to move my hair or something, but I remember my fingers feeling like they were cramping up and I remember thinking I was like -- my face felt like it had all pins and needles so it was hard for me to talk. And her asking me the questions. I remember just thinking, like, Just knock me out. Just do something. What are you doing? And she was asking me if I was allergic to medications, and then she asked me if I was there with anybody, and I said my husband. And she said, "No, he's not here with you." And I said, "Yes, he is." And I said, "He came with me in the ambulance." And she said, "We can't find him." And I remember at that point, I think because I was in so much pain, my patience had just run out, and I remember I definitely snapped at her and I said, "He was in the ambulance with me. Go find him." And then I remember a doctor on the other side of me standing there...

(Pause.)

CELESTE CORCORAN: ...just kind of stoically standing there without a lot of emotion. And he had a clipboard in his hand. And in my mind at that point they were going to fix me. I didn't know what was happening down there but they were going to fix me. And he had this clipboard, and he looked at me and he said, just, you know, so matter-of-factly, he said, "Celeste, Celeste, we need you to sign this because we need to amputate both your legs." And I just remember looking at him and I went, "Both?" And he said, "Yes." And all I could think of at that time was that, you know, they wouldn't be telling me that if that didn't have to happen. I just needed the pain to stop. So I just scribbled my name, and they must have knocked me out after that.

MR. MELLIN: Do you know where Sydney was at that point in time when you were going into surgery?

CELESTE CORCORAN: No, I did not.

MR. MELLIN: At some point later did you learn that she was there at Boston Medical Center at the same time?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes. It was after I woke up. I woke up and they told me that she had been hurt, she had had surgery, and they were going to put us in the same room together. And that's what they did. They brought us in the same room together. At that point I didn't know the extent of her injuries at all, I just knew that my daughter was there. And I was just so glad -- I mean, that my husband was there and my daughter was alive. We just -- I just couldn't stop crying because it was the second time I almost lost her, and I was so glad that she was alive, that she wasn't taken from me.

MR. MELLIN: How long were you and Sydney in the same hospital room?

CELESTE CORCORAN: They put us in the same room for our entire stay. I think we were in the hospital -- my time gets blurred. I think we were there maybe three or four weeks.

MR. MELLIN: And during that time, did you either hear or observe problems she was having or complications she was having?

MR. MELLIN: What were those?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So that was probably the most heartbreaking or heart-wrenching thing as a mom. I am such a mom. I mother everybody. And to see your child in pain and not be able to get up and go to them. So our hospital beds were, you know, on either side of the room, and Sydney had a reaction to I think a pain medication that she had. So she was violently ill. And I just remember just helplessly laying there in my bed watching my daughter be violently ill. And I couldn't get up, I couldn't go to her, I couldn't hear because my eardrums got blown out. So when everyone was hovered around her and talking and saying what they were going to do to her or what was going on, I didn't know what was happening. And that was probably one of the hardest things as well as, you know, just being with her through her recovery, that I've had to go through with her, is seeing her in pain and not being able to go to her and comfort her.

MR. MELLIN: After you were at Boston Medical Center, were you moved to Spaulding Rehab?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes, we were.

MR. MELLIN: The two of you were moved?

CELESTE CORCORAN: We were moved together. We were in adjoining rooms. I believe I stayed for -- it might have been just under two weeks -- and Sydney stayed less than that. I'm not sure if it was four or five, six days.

MR. MELLIN: What were the full extent of the injuries you sustained?

MR. MELLIN: What was the extent of the injuries you sustained? You mentioned your eardrums were blown out at the scene.

MR. MELLIN: What else?

CELESTE CORCORAN: My eardrums were blown out, I had shrapnel that hit my body. My legs -- as a result of the shrapnel that hit my body, I am now a double amputee, one below the knee and one above the knee. And I wear prosthetic limbs. And along my right side -- the blast came from my right side, so along my right side, along my right thigh I have -- and on my face just a little bit, it's almost like -- the doctors told me it's almost like a tattoo. It's like debris, maybe dirt, something that is probably -- it's not big pieces of shrapnel but it's something that will probably be forever embedded in my skin as a constant reminder, as if my legs weren't enough.

MR. MELLIN: How many surgeries did you undergo?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So I had three surgeries, I believe, within that first week on my legs, and then they were able to -- they do the surgeries to remove all the shrapnel and know that they can close it and it's going to be okay, so it required three surgeries, and then they were at a point where they could close it up. And those were the only surgeries on my legs. But then after those surgeries, when I started to lessen -- when I started to need less medication, I realized that a piece of shrapnel had hit my cheek. It didn't penetrate but it had broken my tooth, and a nerve -- my back molar, a nerve was completely exposed. And I can't believe I'm saying this, but, you know, having your legs amputated, when you have a raw nerve that's just exposed, that was pretty painful also. And I couldn't eat. And I was complaining about that. And they said that they couldn't fix it in the hospital because it wasn't, like, oral surgery. I needed to see a regular dentist. But I was in so much agony with that that -- I believe he was a dental resident or something came to see me, and he just did a quick fix. Like he saw what was going on and he put some kind of compound -- he had to jam it in there. And that wasn't fun.

MR. MELLIN: Was that ultimately fixed at some point?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes, after I was -- I believe it was after I came home from Spaulding.

MR. MELLIN: What happened with your eardrums?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So my left ear ended up healing itself. After three months they checked me, and the left ear had healed itself, but my right ear, there wasn't enough of the eardrum to grow back. So I made the decision to get surgery on my ear to rebuild the eardrum. So I had that done. And that was a lot more difficult than I thought it was going to be. I thought, you know, It's my ear. How bad can it be? I lost my legs. But that surgery was really tough and it kind of knocked me down again for a good couple of months. So the surgery was a success in that I now have a functioning eardrum and I don't have a hole there any longer, but my hearing -- they were hoping that my hearing would at least come back to what the other side was, and it did not. So I have significant enough hearing loss in that ear to wear a hearing aid.

MR. MELLIN: As you sit here today, just for the record, you're wearing two prosthetic legs, correct?

MR. MELLIN: One is above the knee and one below the knee?

MR. MELLIN: Are there circulation problems that accompany having double amputations?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I don't know what you mean about circulation problems. I just know that I never forget that I'm a double amputee. I always have -- I wouldn't really call it pain, but it's always a level of discomfort. Right now when I'm wearing my prosthetics I kind of feel -- it's weird, but I feel like I have legs and feet. Like I feel like I'm curling my toes right now, which is a little comforting to me, but right now I'm not comfortable. The bottoms of my limbs are constantly -- there's this constant -- it's like a numb, burning sensation. And a lot of times -- and that's with the prosthetics on. And with the prosthetics off, it comes and goes. Sometimes it feels like -- the only way I can describe it is if -- you feel like you've had the worst athlete's foot in your life. It's like this horrible burning. There's times when I get shooting pains, and it literally makes me catch my breath. Like people notice when that happens to me. When I get those shooting pains, it's strange because I feel it in my feet. It's always my feet. It feels like somebody stabbed a toe or stabbed my heel or my calf or something. But it's usually my feet. So can I get on with my life? Absolutely.

MR. MELLIN: Let me ask you: Did you at some point after the bombings get a service dog?

MR. MELLIN: Did you get a service dog?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I did get a service dog.

MR. MELLIN: What is the name of your service dog?

MR. MELLIN: Sebastian's not in the courtroom today, correct?

CELESTE CORCORAN: No, he's in the other room waiting for me.

MR. MELLIN: All right. And exactly what assistance does Sebastian provide you?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So he helps with my mobility. I -- as a double amputee, I have problems just walking. You know, on a flat surface it's easier, but walking -- I'm still not comfortable. I still haven't ventured out by myself walking on the sidewalk or -- an uneven surface, you don't realize until you're a double amputee how many dips and hills or whatever there are, inclines there are. Inclines are the worse [sic]. Going up is fine, but the inclines are very hard, and he helps me navigate those. He has a harness, and I hold on to the harness and he braces me. And if I've fallen, he's trained to -- I get up by myself but then -- well, partly get up, and then I can put my -- I can tell him to brace, and I can put my hand on his shoulder and he braces for me, to put a little bit more of my weight to get up.

MR. MELLIN: If I could have you look at a few photographs, please. Exhibit 9 which is already in evidence.

CELESTE CORCORAN: I should have brought my glasses.

MR. MELLIN: I believe Ms. Conrad has some that you can use.

CELESTE CORCORAN: May I? Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: As you look at Exhibit 9, who do you recognize in that photograph?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I see my husband.

MR. MELLIN: And if you could, please, just draw a circle around Mr. Corcoran.

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: And you drew a circle around the man in a red coat in the middle of the photograph. Is that right?

MR. MELLIN: At that time he's over the top of you?

MR. MELLIN: Okay. Do you see your daughter Sydney?

MR. MELLIN: Would you please circle her?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: And for the record, you drew a circle around the woman who's down on the ground by the black fencing?

MR. MELLIN: Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: If I could have Exhibit 13, please.

THE COURT: Also in evidence?

MR. MELLIN: Yes, your Honor.

BY MR. MELLIN:

MR. MELLIN: And for the record, who is shown in Exhibit 13?

CELESTE CORCORAN: That's my daughter.

MR. MELLIN: If I could have you look at Exhibit 12, please.

MR. MELLIN: Also in evidence, your Honor.

MR. MELLIN: Mrs. Corcoran, as you look at Exhibit 12, do you see yourself?

MR. MELLIN: Could you please circle yourself?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: For the record, you're the woman with the gray top on that's being assisted by the man in the red coat?

MR. MELLIN: And again, that's your husband, Kevin Corcoran?

MR. MELLIN: All right. Do you know Mary Daniel?

MR. MELLIN: And how do you know Mary?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Through Spaulding Rehab.

MR. MELLIN: And do you know if she had a leg that was amputated?

MR. MELLIN: Do you see her in this photograph?

MR. MELLIN: Could you circle her, please?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: And for the record, you circled the woman who's essentially in the middle of the photograph, I think wearing white. It's really hard to tell in that photo. Is that right?

MR. MELLIN: Okay. And do you see the individual just below Ms. Daniel in that photograph?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I see Jeff Bauman.

MR. MELLIN: Okay. Thank you.

CELESTE CORCORAN: With his legs sticking out. His raw legs sticking out.

MR. MELLIN: And finally, if I could have you look at Exhibit 20 --

MR. MELLIN: Which is in evidence, your Honor.

MR. MELLIN: Mrs. Corcoran, as you look at Exhibit 20, do you see yourself in that photograph?

MR. MELLIN: And could you circle where you are in Exhibit 20?

CELESTE CORCORAN: (Witness complies.)

MR. MELLIN: For the record, you've circled the woman at the top right corner of the photograph?

MR. MELLIN: And do you see someone with their hand on your leg wearing a red coat?

MR. MELLIN: What is going on there?

CELESTE CORCORAN: I believe my husband is applying pressure to my legs.

MR. MELLIN: Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: Thank you, your Honor.

If I may just have one moment.

(Counsel confer off the record.)

BY MR. MELLIN:

MR. MELLIN: May I have you look at Exhibit 1449, which I'm not sure is in evidence.

MR. MELLIN: Just for the witness, please.

MR. MELLIN: Do you recognize Exhibit 1449?

CELESTE CORCORAN: That's my daughter Sydney. That's her legs.

MR. MELLIN: Is that a fair and accurate photograph of the scars on her legs?

CELESTE CORCORAN: It's not all of them, but, yes, it is.

MR. MELLIN: Your Honor, we would move into evidence Exhibit 1449 and ask to publish.

MS. CLARKE: Subject to the earlier objection.

THE COURT: All right. Overruled and admitted.

(Government Exhibit No. 1449 received into evidence.)

BY MR. MELLIN:

MR. MELLIN: Mrs. Corcoran, as we look at Exhibit 1449, you said that's some of the scars but not all of them. Can you describe the scar that's on the left inner thigh of your daughter Sydney?

CELESTE CORCORAN: The scar on the left is where they took a vein or artery from her leg to put it on the right-hand side where her femoral artery was severed, to reattach her femoral artery.

MR. MELLIN: Okay. And the reattachment, was that the scarring that we see at the top of her thigh on 1449?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Which side? It's -- I'm sorry.

MR. MELLIN: Can you describe the two scars that you see on the right leg of your daughter?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Okay. So on my daughter's right leg -- can I circle?

CELESTE CORCORAN: So on my daughter's right leg, right here is where a piece of the pressure cooker went into her leg.

MR. MELLIN: And just for the record, as you look at 1449, that's the scar on the farthest left of the photograph?

CELESTE CORCORAN: It went into her femoral artery. And you don't see, but up here, the piece of the bomb, it was the size of a cell phone, and it was in her leg here and sticking out here. So it severed her femoral artery, so they took a vein from here and attached it here where she was damaged, where she almost bled out from (indicating).

MR. MELLIN: All right. So you started with the scar on the farthest left on this photograph, is that right, as you're looking at it?

CELESTE CORCORAN: The scar on her left is --

MR. MELLIN: No, no, no. In the photo. I'm totally confusing you.

MR. MELLIN: As you look at this photograph, the scar on the left is the entry wound of a piece of the pressure cooker?

MR. MELLIN: And then you indicated that it went through and was embedded in the --

CELESTE CORCORAN: Right here. Up.

MR. MELLIN: -- area between her thighs?

MR. MELLIN: Is that fair to say?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes. She was very close to losing her leg.

MR. MELLIN: And so then the surgeons took an artery out of her left leg and put it in the right leg, and that's attached to the scar that is kind of running down the middle of her thigh?

CELESTE CORCORAN: Yes. And both those scars -- may I say this? Both those scars go all the way up here (indicating).

MR. MELLIN: And for the record now, you just indicated that the scars go from what is shown in 1449, they go up to almost her -- the base of her abdomen?

MR. MELLIN: You also mentioned there is other scarring as well. What other scarring did she have or does she have?

CELESTE CORCORAN: She had a hole blown through her foot, she had -- so she has no feeling. Do you want me to elaborate on that?

MR. MELLIN: A little bit, yes. Go ahead.

CELESTE CORCORAN: She had a hole blown through her foot. So her -- if this is her foot, the hole was blown through right here, and she's missing this bone in her foot so her pinky toe is like -- it has no feeling whatsoever; it's just attached by tendons. She has numerous other shrapnel wounds, but what you don't see on her legs in those pictures, because they're of her thighs, is on her right leg, where the graft was done, she has on her calf -- I'm sorry -- on her calf she has two incisions that go the entire length of her calf that basically look like two zippers. And I'm not a doctor, but I believe it was called compartmental syndrome, because when they reattached the veins and arteries, there's a danger of, like, too much blood flow going down there, so they need to make those incisions so that basically her leg would just kind of blow up. So she has those scars also. I'm trying to think. Just other, you know, scarring on her whole leg from different pieces of shrapnel.

MR. MELLIN: Thank you.

MR. MELLIN: Thank you, your Honor.

MS. CLARKE: Thank you very much. No questions.

THE COURT: No questions?

All right, Ms. Corcoran. Thank you. You may step down. You're excused.

(The witness is excused.)

THE COURT: We'll take a short recess.

Jurors, again, you know what I'm going to say. No discussion of the evidence in the case. There will be a time for that, but it is certainly not now.

We'll take a 15-minute recess.

COURT CLERK: All rise for the Court and the jury. The Court will be in recess.

(The Court and jury exit the courtroom and there is a recess in the proceedings at 11:54 a.m.)

COURT CLERK: All rise for the Court.

(The Court enters the courtroom at 12:16 p.m.)

THE COURT: I understand counsel would like to be seen.

Continue to next page9.Mistrial Motion over Survivor Testimony and Objection Requirements