6.Michael Sullivan — Direct
126 linesMICHAEL SULLIVAN, Sworn
COURT CLERK: Have a seat. State your name. Spell your first and last name for the record. Keep your voice up and speak into the mic.
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Okay. Michael Sullivan, M-i-c-h-a-e-l, S-u-l-l-i-v-a-n.
DIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. WATKINS:
MR. WATKINS: Good afternoon, Mr. Sullivan. How are you currently employed?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I'm currently a paramedic employed by the Public Health Commission for the City of Boston.
MR. WATKINS: How long have you worked at the Health Commission?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Thirty-one years.
MR. WATKINS: What -- can you briefly describe some of the positions you've held over the years at the Boston Health Commission?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I first got hired as an EMT and emergency medical technician and then was promoted to paramedic in 1987.
MR. WATKINS: Can I ask you to pull that mic just a little bit closer to you? Thank you. Describe what you need to do in order to become a paramedic.
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: First, you need to take a -- you have to be an EMT, which is generally a 100- or 110-hour course. After you take that, you're certified as an EMT. Then you can take the paramedic program, which is generally a 2000-hour course. It was when I took it. The clinical, didactic, and then a field internship. Then you get to take the national registry test and get certified as a paramedic.
MR. WATKINS: When did you first become certified as a paramedic?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: In 1987.
MR. WATKINS: Do you regularly get recertified as a paramedic?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: You have to recertify every two years.
MR. WATKINS: Now, in the city of Boston is there more than one kind of ambulance team?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: The Boston deploys a two-tier response system staffed by basic life support ambulances, which is the majority of the ambulances, and advanced life support ambulances, which are staffed by paramedics.
MR. WATKINS: So do you staff an advanced life support?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I do.
MR. WATKINS: Are there EMTs on any of the advanced life support?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: No. It's staffed by two paramedics.
MR. WATKINS: How many ambulances does the Boston Public Health Commission have on the road at any given time?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, it depends. Days and evenings, it's generally -- depending on staffing but generally 20 basic life support ambulances and five advance life support ambulances, days and evenings. And at night, the staffing drops to 15 basic life support ambulances and three advance life support ambulances.
MR. WATKINS: There are ambulances on the road 24 hours a day?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: There is.
MR. WATKINS: What -- in 2013, what shifts were you working?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I was working the midnight -- the night shift or the midnight shift. My shift was 11 p.m. to 7 a.m.
MR. WATKINS: That would be the 11 p.m. at the end of one day to 7 a.m. the next?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Correct.
MR. WATKINS: On April 18th, what shift -- were you working that same shift?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I was, yes.
MR. WATKINS: Describe that shift initially when you came on at 11 p.m. What kind of activities did you do?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We came in at 11:00. We did our normal shift change. And we did our normal drug count, the things we normally do. And then our operations center, which is known as The Turret, sent us to a person in the water behind the aquarium. So we responded to that. And when we got there, there was one of our BLS ambulances already there, and the fire department responded and the police -- Harbor Patrol responded. So we went down and assisted them. Someone had already taken them out of the water, and we assisted them bringing the patient up to the street.
MR. WATKINS: Did you answer another call after that?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: No, no. We didn't have another call after that. While we were on the way there, the police office had advised us that there was a shooting in Cambridge of a police officer and that they had went to the Mass. General. So we headed over to the Mass. General to see what was happening over there.
MR. WATKINS: Now, at some point were you directed to go someplace else?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We were. Shortly after we left the Mass. General, we were dispatched to an unconscious subject in East Boston, and we left the Mass. General and headed towards East Boston.
MR. WATKINS: What happened on that call?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We got canceled from that call, and we proceeded to the Frontage Road, which is a fueling area. That's where we fueled up our truck. And we got a call from there to the airport for an unconscious person.
MR. WATKINS: Did you go out to the airport?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We did. We responded to Terminal A at the airport. And on the way there, we had -- one of our shift commanders had fallen in behind us. He took a different route, but we ended up arriving at the same time.
MR. WATKINS: This is over at the airport?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: At the airport, Terminal A.
MR. WATKINS: Was there a time after that that you were dispatched to Brighton?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: On the way to the airport, we had the scanner in the ambulance on. And they had said that there was a carjacking in Brighton, and they were in the Cambridge/Brighton area. And they had updated that it was in -- it happened in Brighton. So the Boston Police sent their available units in Brighton to the Brighton/Watertown line.
MR. WATKINS: What happens when police are dispatched to a particular area in that manner?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, that particular part of the city falls in our district. That's part of our response area. So when the police responded there, we started in that direction so that we would be closer to the area if something should happen or if they would need us.
MR. WATKINS: Did you make it to Brighton in your truck?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: No. On the way to the -- on the way to Brighton on the Mass. Pike, we had a breakdown with our vehicle, and we had to coast to the -- after the tollbooths, coast to the bottom of the ramp. And the shift commander that was behind us, he pulled up to us and -- you know, What happened? The truck broke down so we need to go with you. We ended up jumping in the supervisor vehicle, and then we proceeded out to -- out Western Avenue towards the Brighton/Watertown line.
MR. WATKINS: Did you end up going all the way into Watertown?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We did. Along the way, as events there had unfolded and the police activity had increased, our operations center sent us directly to Dexter Street in Watertown.
MR. WATKINS: Did you end up going directly to Dexter Street with the shift commander?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We didn't get completely to the incident location. We got to Dexter, near Arsenal Street. Right in that general area, we ended up stopping there and getting out of the vehicle.
MR. WATKINS: Why did you stop there, do you know?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We stopped there -- that was the beginning of Dexter, but we didn't know where our other unit was. We were going to meet up with the BLS truck, or the basic life support truck, but we didn't know where they were. We were on the radio. Can you tell us where you are? Can you tell us where you are? We were kind of hovering around that area. Shortly after that they came around Dexter Street towards us.
MR. WATKINS: When you say they came around Dexter Street, who was that?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: That was the District 14 ambulance, A14.
MR. WATKINS: Is that the BLS truck that's part of your two-tier system?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: It is.
MR. WATKINS: What happened when you saw that truck coming towards you?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: They were coming out of the street, so we made notice that we were there to intercept with them. And they stopped, and we opened up the back doors of the truck and got into the ambulance.
MR. WATKINS: So who jumped into the truck once the basic life support truck came?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I entered through the back door, and my partner entered through the side door.
MR. WATKINS: And did the EMTs that were there get out, both of them?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: One got out and the other stayed inside.
MR. WATKINS: Were there also law enforcement officers inside the truck?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: There were. There were two Boston police officers in the vehicle, too.
MR. WATKINS: Now, once you and your -- who was your partner that night as part of the advance life support team?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: That was Sean Murphy.
MR. WATKINS: Once you and Sean Murphy got into the truck, do you take over assigned roles?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yeah. We generally will get in the truck, and generally who was at the head of the patient will be the one that will kind of, like, run the call and document the call. It's, like, your call. I had got in the back and started my evaluation from that part of the patient. And he got in the side door and started the evaluation from the head down to the waist.
MR. WATKINS: The person at the head, does that team member also do an assessment of the patient?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yeah. That's what we actually did. The person at the head would do from the head to the waist, and the person from the feet would do from the feet to the waist. And we'd do an exam that way.
MR. WATKINS: So where did you ultimately end up in the truck? Were you at the head or the feet?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Somewhere along the line in the back of the ambulance, we ended up swapping positions. I was at the head and Sean was at the feet.
MR. WATKINS: What did you observe about the patient that was in the truck when you got there?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: When I first got in the truck, I noticed that he had multiple trauma, and he had some -- and road rash. And we asked the police, you know, What -- What happened? And they said, Well, you know, he was the suspect, and these are the injuries that he has.
MR. WATKINS: And they gave you what they thought the injuries were?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yeah. They initially -- when I asked about the road rash, they said, No, no, no. It was a blast-type injury from an errant explosive device.
MR. WATKINS: What other things could you personally see in your observation and assessment of the patient?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: He had some other penetrating trauma. Some looked like they were apparent gunshot wounds, and others looked like shrapnel-type-appearing wounds.
MR. WATKINS: Did you later learn that that patient was Tamerlan Tsarnaev?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, all we knew is that he was the suspect. We didn't have a name.
MR. WATKINS: Later on, you came to understand that you had transported Tamerlan Tsarnaev?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Right. On the way, we received that information.
MR. WATKINS: Does your assessment also include an assessment of whether they're oriented and conscious?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yeah. The first thing we'll try to do is the general appearance of the patient, and then we'll try to establish a level of consciousness. He was pale. He was sweaty. And he was looking at us -- we were making eye contact, so we knew he was awake. But the skin condition and the mechanism of injury from the trauma that he had, we suspected that he was in shock.
MR. WATKINS: Now, when he was in the basic life support truck when you got in, was he still handcuffed?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: He was, yes.
MR. WATKINS: Was there any attempt to take the handcuffs off of him?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: No. The police department had -- he was in custody and that's their policy, is to -- he had to remain in handcuffs.
MR. WATKINS: What did you also observe about his general demeanor as he was in the truck?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, the first thing we did was try to treat him. So I initially -- where do you hurt? Do you have trouble breathing? But I had no -- he didn't answer us. So -- but we knew we had to start treating him. And the first line of treatment would be an I.V. So we wanted to get an I.V. and we could treat his shock with the fluids. We could also, if we needed to, sedate him to put a tube in his lungs and resuscitate him.
MR. WATKINS: When you tried to do that first, put the I.V., what happened?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, during our exam, it was when everybody was hands on, he got -- he got combative, and he was resisting our attempts to intervene and treat him. For some reason, the stretcher that he was on would normally have a chest strap across his chest. For some reason that was lower. It was around his waist. So when we attempted to intervene and treat him, he would lift himself up off the stretcher and yell and scream and try to resist us touching him to try to treat him. When Sean tried to prep his legs -- we couldn't get I.V. in his arms because he was handcuffed. So when we tried to prep his legs for intraosseous -- intravenous line, just that attempt, he would get resistive -- resisted the treatment and would squirm around and try to get away from what we were attempting to do. And multiple times he'd pull up off the stretcher and --
MR. WATKINS: And what about noise, what was he doing?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: He was yelling loud, you know, like a "ghurrr" type of attempt when he stood up to -- it seemed like he was trying to get out of the seatbelts that were holding him on and resisting our attempts to treat him.
MR. WATKINS: Now, in your several decades of experience there, you've had combative patients before?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yes.
MR. WATKINS: You have had patients who have tried to get out of the ambulance before?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yes.
MR. WATKINS: And this was consistent with that kind of experience, of somebody just trying to get out?
MR. MELLIN: Objection.
THE COURT: Overruled. Go ahead.
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Well, that and his -- the injuries that he had and he being in shock, you would get anxious from that, and, you know, that's a typical response to hypoxia or shock.
MR. WATKINS: By this time, the ambulance was moving towards the trauma center?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We started towards the Beth Israel. That was the nearest trauma center.
MR. WATKINS: That was very quickly after you climbed inside at the same time you were trying to treat Tamerlan Tsarnaev?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yes.
MR. WATKINS: Did you also try to bandage a head wound that you saw on him?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: We tried -- yeah, we tried to bandage his head wound. He had an abdominal wound which was an evisceration. It's a penetrating injury to the abdomen where the intestines come out of your abdomen. So we tried to dress that. But every time we tried hands on, he resisted the treatment.
MR. WATKINS: How long did it take you to get to the trauma center?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: I believe it was five minutes, six minutes, around that line.
MR. WATKINS: With the behaviors he had and the yelling that he did, was it possible to treat him at all during that entire period?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: No, no. We could do -- we could try to keep him flat so that he wouldn't sit up and drop his blood pressure further. I think we put the bed in Trendelenburg to do basic type treatments for the shock, but he would not allow us to treat him any further than that.
MR. WATKINS: That's when you pulled up to the trauma center and passed him off there?
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Yeah. We notified the Beth Israel that we were coming in, so they were waiting for us. We got out of the truck and brought him straight into the trauma room.
MR. WATKINS: That's all the questions I have, your Honor.
MR. MELLIN: No questions, your Honor. Thank you.
THE COURT: All right, sir. Thank you. You may step down.
MICHAEL SULLIVAN: Thank you.
MR. WATKINS: Your Honor, the defense calls Laura Lee.
MR. MELLIN: Your Honor, this was a witness we had an issue with.
THE COURT: Yes. The exhibits may be admitted.
COURT CLERK: Ma'am, want to step up here, please. Step up to the box, if you would. Remain standing. Raise your right hand.